Customer Rating: 



Review Summary: Play the Game
Review: A lot of reviews cover the chapters and describe some of the stuff inside, and that's great; it's super helpful stuff and a great start to help someone decide whether or not they want to buy this book. But this isn't a book to sit down and read. If you just want to read a book, buy an actual novel. This is a Role Playing Game. You have to actually play the game to figure out if you like it or not.
Like any Role Playing Game, this game is really only as solid as the person running it (DM for D&Ders, GM for most other games, Storytellers for WoD fans). If the person running the game is clueless, the game isn't fun. If the person running the game is a creative person, already familiar with World of Darkness and has at least skimmed the rules for Mage, the game is going to be fun.
The game play mechanics are simplified so that you aren't spending an hour rolling dice to find out whether or not you've smacked someone upside the head. The magic is complicated because it's magic. You can do, literally, anything with it. If you can't think of your own applications for magic, this book provides tons of examples of things that you can do and those are all pretty simple to use, even though it may take a lot of referencing during game-play.
Bottom line:
If you don't play RPG's, start with something a little easier. Maybe start with just a mortal character in the World of Darkness or perhaps something out of the Second Sight book.
If you play RPG's, this book is worth putting aside your normal game for some test play. Chances are pretty good that you'll enjoy it, but make sure that the Storyteller knows what they are doing.
Customer Rating: 



Review Summary: How WW managed to murder one of the best concept mainstream RPG games
Review: This game used to be the best by far in old WoD edition. Seriously, I don't understand how could people who developed something as cool and inventive as the old Mage come up with this piece of manure.
Just don't buy it. Save yourself the pain.
Customer Rating: 



Review Summary: Background Travesty
Review: The game rules are not terrible. They are fairly streamlined and idiot-proof. However, WW apparently could only simplify the rules by simplifying the background material. They took a wonderfully open-ended and absolutely brilliant background world (the consensual reality) and stripped it down to a cartoonish and rather silly Atlantis myth. Terrible. Just Terrible.
I also find it amusing that they cleared out all of the metaplot history in Vampire to make the game more open to interpretation and less confined by metalplot events, and then went and eviscerated the background of MAGE, the WOD game that was MOST open to interpretation. A pale and dumbed down version of MAGE for the WOW generation...
Customer Rating: 



Review Summary: new mage in world of darkness
Review: i used ot play the old vampire the masquerade and i had little to no knowledge of mages or mage culture except some bargains i had struck with NPCs. so looking into the new world of darkness i was pretty interested in buying this book.
it is really good, although i have not played as a mage yet, i would recomend this to any world of darkness player as a bit of research material.
white wolf does a good job making their books worth reading.
Customer Rating: 



Review Summary: It used to be such a cool game...
Review: I've always liked the Storyteller game system used in the World of Darkness. Back in college I had a lot of fun playing Mage using the old system, which was full of great concepts and fun ideas. I picked up the new book after I started playing in a World of Darkness campaign, optimistic about the changes they've made. Wow, what a disappointment.
I agree with many of the other critical reviews here. The 9 Traditions from the old book were far more interesting and evocative than the rather generic Paths and Orders offered in this book. The consensual reality of the old game was far inspired than the dull myth of Atlantis that they wheel out for the new version. Basically they've gotten rid of everything I really loved and replaced it with ideas that feel plain in comparison.
The book has very high production value and a cool cover, but that doesn't overcome the fact that the book is poorly organized, confusing, and overwritten.
That said, it's still a good game system and still a lot of fun to play. Given the choice, I'd rather play the old Mage, but I imagine new players to the game will enjoy this quite a bit.